We Serve the Injured. Big City Experience. Warm Southern Approach.

Proving an Accident Related Injury

Excuses the Insurance Industry Uses To Deny Disk Herniation Claims

Someone is in a bad car accident and is subsequently diagnosed with a painful disc herniation for the first time. Sounds like an easy case to prove, right? Wrong. Proving to a suspicious insurance company that a disc herniation is related to the accident-related trauma is easier said than done.

Some of the lamest excuses Attorney Burnside has heard in his career from insurance companies and their lawyers and hired “independent” doctors include, but are not limited to:

  • Top Excuse: “Although the claimant never sought medical care for their disc herniation prior to the accident, the claimant is old and the disc herniation is related to age.”
  • Runner-up: “Although the claimant never sought medical care for their disc herniation prior to the accident, the claimant:
    • If they worked/work a labor-intensive job: “It’s caused from their job”
    • If they work a sedentary job or don’t work: “It’s from sitting a lot.”
  • Third Place: “There’s probably something in the claimant’s distant past that caused the disc herniation.”
  • “Disc herniation can be caused from sneezing too hard.”
  • “Disc herniation is not painful.”
  • Honorable Mention: “Disc herniation can heal themselves”

Proving a Disk Herniation Case in Court

Attorney Burnside has tried several of these types of cases to juries. But these cases are not easy and remain some of the toughest cases to prove because of several of the factors the opposing sides use to

Proving a permanent disk herniation case rests in proving the following underlying issues:

  • Liability: we must first prove that the other party is fully at-fault
  • Mechanism of injury: we must prove how the disc herniation occurred. Was it a whiplash-type motion of the neck, or was there a significant “jolt” of the mid or low back that caused the force necessary for these types of injuries?
  • Absence of prior issues versus: if a client has had no prior vertebral pain or documented injury from to the car accident, or another event that caused their injury, it becomes a matter of common knowledge that if it wasn’t there before, and was after a trauma, that is it related to the trauma. This is usually an easier argument than that of establishing an aggravation of a preexisting injury.
  • Establishing that there was an “aggravation”: when the opposing side argues that our clients who have had preexisting structural issues in the spine (also referred to as “eggshell plaintiffs”), it can be a dagger in a client’s case if not treated properly. Many people think that if they had a pre-existing spinal issue that juries will automatically believe that the new herniation was there all along. That is not true. On the other hand, the law recognizes that people are more susceptible to receiving a disc herniation if they previously had damage that would predispose them to further injury. Sometimes proving a disc injury when there are pre-existing problems is easier to establish in court as the argument can be made that the new traumatic event “was the stick that broke the camel’s back.”

Compare the following that sometimes is argued in court: When you sprain your ankle, everyone knows you are more susceptible to another injury to that same ankle. The damage to the ligaments is a similar type of damage to that that surround and make up the spine. Once damaged, they tend to never go back to the way they were.

Getting it Right

In order to prove that your disc herniation is a result of the accident, and therefore a result of someone else’s negligence, it’s important that you have your injury diagnosed by a doctor. In most cases, a chiropractor’s diagnosis is not enough.

Our firm is committed to helping you fight for your rights after a serious injury leaves you dealing with life-altering consequences. Our Portsmouth disc herniation attorneys understand this complex area of personal injury law and are prepared to aggressively advocate for you every step of the way.

If you’d like to discuss your case with our experienced disc herniation attorney in the Tri-State area, call Burnside Law at (888) 724-9319!

Contact Us Today!
Office Location


1118 Hutchins Street,
Suite A
Portsmouth, OH 45662
Map & Directions [+]

Real Stories From Real People

  • “Burnside Law was a great match for me. They kept me informed throughout the whole process. I could not be happier with the representation that I received.”

    - Gary
  • “Jeremy and his staff treated my husband and I like family. They were very professional, caring and continued to help make a difference in my life after the accident and even after the case closed. We ...”

    - Lena
  • “I was so happy to get a referral to Burnside Law LLC; they have been terrific to me. Thank you, Burnside Law”

    - Shelba
  • “This was our first experience using a lawyer. We found Burnside Law, LLC to be very efficient, and would highly recommend them to others.”

    - Frank and Helen
  • “Burnside Law was very helpful and informative. They kept me updated on everything that was going on. I would recommend them if you are in need of their assistance. Thank you for all the help.”

    - Past Client

Our Video Library

Additional Resources to Better Help You

Place Your Confidence

In Burnside Law, LLC
  • No Fees Unless We Win

    No attorney's fees are charged unless we reach a recovery for your case.*

  • Free Case Reviews

    We offer FREE case reviews in all personal injury, nursing home, and wrongful death cases.

  • Treating You Like Family

    Our legal team strives to help our clients feel like family, an important factor in achieving peace of mind.

  • Always Available

    Our firm makes it easy for clients to reach out to us at anytime throughout their case.

  • Network of Resources

    We have several connections throughout the legal community that we use as valuable resources to answer complex issues.

Contact Us

Schedule a Free Confidential Case Review
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.